Activities
OctoberDecember 2000
Executive
Summary
During
the period under review, Center faculty were busy in three principal
activities. First was teaching and lecturing, with Sofia Gruskin and
Stephen Marks each teaching a course and Stephen Marks, Sofia Gruskin,
and Jennifer Leaning each delivering several lectures, keynote addresses
or panel presentations. Second,
it was also a period of negotiating Center involvement in significant
future events, such as the Temple University conference to honor Jonathan
Mann’s memory and the course for USAID. The
third salient feature was faculty involvement in major international
events, primarily the annual meeting of the American Public Health Association,
where our faculty ran a continuing education institute, put together
and chaired a plenary session and spoke in two substantive panels, and
Africa Now!, a summit of U.S. and African leaders. All
three programs continued to strengthen relations with their respective
partners, including WHO, UNAIDS, the ICRC, USAID, and UNDP.
The
report follows the usual structure of dealing first with the core activities
in education, training, linkages and information, and then reviewing
developments in the three programs during the fourth quarter of 2000.
Core
Activities
Fall
courses continued in this period. Stephen Marks concluded his new course
Development and Human Rights. The student evaluations rated the course
and the teaching assistant very highly. Also in this period, Sofia Gruskin
began teaching Health and Human Rights. This year there are approximately
25 students with a range of backgrounds and experience.
Jennifer Leaning
has worked with two colleagues to develop a course on responses to epidemic
disease and bioterrorism. The draft proposal, with syllabus, has been
submitted to the HSPH/PIH curriculum committee. A seminar version of
this course will be taught in the “D” period.
Visiting
Committee
On October
26–27, Stephen Marks participated in the HSPH Visiting Committee Meeting.
This year, the Visiting Committee’s strategic focus was an examination
of the role of centers at the school. Stephen Marks made a presentation
to the Committee on the FXBC, including discussion of current activities
and plans for the future. The discussion with the Committee was engaging;
their questions were both interested and thoughtful, and their feedback
was very positive. Stephen Marks also participated in the Advisory Committee
meeting for the Department of Population and International Health, where
he made a presentation on globalization, health, and human rights.
Intensive
Course on Health and Human Rights
During
this period, planning continued for the 2001 Intensive Course on Health
and Human Rights. Conversations continued with Michael Grodin and George
Annas of BU, and preliminary planning began for next year’s course.
Feedback from the June 2000 course was extremely positive and included
a number of suggestions that are being incorporated into planning for
the June 2001 course. Two of these changes are lengthening the program
(from 3 to 3.5 days) and adding Jennifer Leaning as a Course Director.
Discussions with the CCPE Office continued during this time regarding
the administration of next June’s course.
Emergency
Medicine Program on International and Disaster Medicine
Jennifer
Leaning is working with partners at Harvard Medical School and the Brigham
and Women’s Hospital to develop a year-long fellowship in the Department
of Emergency Medicine at BWH. She supervises a fellow who, in this period,
completed an intensive ICRC course in complex emergencies conducted
in South Africa and is now working as an apprentice in a field hospital
in Malawi. Jennifer Leaning is working with the director of this HMS/Brigham
program to plan the expansion of this program to include several fellows
for next year.
Presentations/Guest
Lectures
On October
11, Sofia Gruskin gave a lecture on “Human Rights and HIV/AIDS” for
this year’s students in the Arthur Ashe Program in AIDS Care at HSPH.
On October
17, Stephen Marks gave a guest lecture on priority issues in health
and human rights at the Human Rights Program at Harvard Law School.
On October
26, Sofia Gruskin gave a guest lecture on reproductive health and women’s
rights in the Harvard Medical School course “Medicine, Human Rights
and the Physician,” taught by Carola Eisenberg and Kris Heggenhougen.
On November
27, Mindy Roseman gave a talk on reproductive rights in the U.S. for
the Harvard Medical School chapter of Medical Students for Choice.
On November
30, Sofia Gruskin gave a guest lecture on HIV/AIDS and human rights
in Saidi Kapiga’s HSPH course “The Frontiers of Knowledge in HIV/AIDS
Prevention, Care and Research.”
On December
4, Stephen Marks presented a guest lecture, “Human Rights and Reconciliation:
Impunity in Cambodia and Chad,” at the Program on International Conflict
Analysis and Resolution (PICAR) at the Weatherhead Center for International
Affairs.
On December
5, Jennifer Leaning and Stephen Marks participated in a symposium at
Harvard Law School titled “Children under Fire: Challenging Concepts
and Facing New Realities.” The keynote address was given by Olara A.
Otunnu, Special Representative of the United Nations Secretary-General
for Children and Armed Conflict. Jennifer Leaning chaired one of the
two panels, on childhood within the context of armed conflict and issues
of vulnerability. The second panel focused on agency and the cultural
context of recovery with particular attention to the topics of displaced/refugee
children and child soldiers.
Human
Rights Day 2000 at Harvard
On December
11, FXB Center staff and students from the Health and Human Rights Student
Group collaborated to present a Human Rights Day screening of several
human rights videos produced by Amnesty International–USA and Physicians
for Human Rights in the HSPH cafeteria. The collaboration with the students
was productive, and we expect it to become an expanding tradition in
coming years.
Beyond
Harvard
American
Public Health Association
FXB Center
faculty participated in many activities at the annual APHA meeting,
in Boston in November. On November 12, Stephen Marks, Sofia Gruskin,
and Jennifer Leaning taught a Continuing Education Institute titled
“Human Rights for Public Health Professionals.” This day-long course,
attended by 25 public health professionals from around the country,
provided a comprehensive introduction to the field of health and human
rights, including sessions on: the application of human rights framework
to public health policies; the health dimensions of international humanitarian
law; HIV/AIDS, human rights, and vulnerability; complex humanitarian
emergencies and relief; and human rights in development. The course
was very well received, and evaluation form feedback was extremely positive.
On Wednesday,
November 15, Stephen Marks chaired a special plenary session on human
rights titled “Social Justice and Human Rights: Implications for Our
Work and Lives.” The large main conference hall, where the session took
place, was filled with some 2000 participants in attendance. He had
set up the panel in cooperation with Russell Morgan, the chair of the
APHA International Human Rights Committee (IHRC). The other panelists
were Cheryl Easley (IHRC), Allan Herman (South Africa), Loretta Ross
(National Center for Human Rights Education, Atlanta), Rebecca Cook
(University of Toronto), and Jack Geiger (Professor Emeritus, CUNY Medical
School).
Finally, on
November 15, Stephen Marks, Sofia Gruskin, and Jennifer Leaning served
as panelists in a two-part panel on health and human rights, chaired
by George Annas of the BU School of Public Health and cosponsored by
the Consortium for Health and Human Rights. In the first session, “The
Right to Health,” Sofia Gruskin gave a talk titled “The Right to Health
and What It Means Internationally,” and Stephen Marks gave a talk titled
“From Legal Norm to Development Practice: How to Implement the Right
to Health.” In the second session, “Health and Human Rights in Practice:
Professional Obligation in Health Practice,” Jennifer Leaning gave a
talk titled “Human Rights Dilemmas in Humanitarian Relief.”
USAID
Course
During
this period, planning continued for a course on health and human rights
for field and Washington-based staff of the U.S. Agency for International
Development (USAID). Both Stephen Marks and Sofia Gruskin were asked
to be a part of the course faculty and course development. It was agreed
that the course would be held in January 2001 at the Foreign Source
Training Institute near Washington, DC, and that Stephen Marks would
coordinate the academic program. On November 15, he and Sofia Gruskin
met with representatives from USAID and other course faculty to plan
for the January course.
Boston
Celebration of Human Rights Day 2000
FXB Center
staff also collaborated with Amnesty International–USA and a number
of other local NGOs to present a symposium in honor of Human Rights
Day titled “Torture: An Affront to Human Dignity.” The event, held on
December 10 at the Boston Public Library, presented a number of scholars
and survivors, including Pumla Gobodo-Madikezela, a psychologist and
former member of the South African Truth and Reconciliation Commission.
Topics covered included the scope of torture worldwide, legal issues
facing torture survivors in the U.S., and healing and recovery.
Presentations/Guest
Lectures
On October
5–6, Jennifer Leaning gave a presentation on human security at the Year
One Review Workshop of USAID/CERTI in Arlington, VA.
On December
4, Jennifer Leaning gave a talk at MIT titled “Assessing the Demographic
Impact of the Partition of India: A Feasibility Study.” The talk was
sponsored by the MIT-Mellon Inter-University Program on Non-Governmental
Organizations and Forced Migration.
On December
8, Stephen Marks made a keynote presentation, “Major Issues in Health
and Human Rights,” at the University of Minnesota’s Health and Human
Rights Symposium. The symposium was cosponsored by the International
Medical Education and Research Program and the Continuing Medical Education
division of the University of Minnesota Medical School, the Human Rights
Center of the University of Minnesota Law School, and the Center For
Victims of Torture, among others. It was directed to an audience of
approximately 300 people as part of continuing professional education.
He was also invited by the director of the Center for Victims of Torture
to tour that facility and meet the staff.
FXB
Center Linkages and Partnerships
With
NGOs and Other Institutions
Temple
University
In this
period, Stephen Marks and Sofia Gruskin met with representatives of
Temple University to discuss possible collaboration on a health and
human rights conference in honor of Jonathan Mann, to be held on September
29–October 1, 2001 in Philadelphia. It was agreed that the FXB Center
would provide assistance with setting the conference program. On October
20, Stephen Marks and Sofia Gruskin met with Scott Burris and Zita Lazzarini
at the office of the American Foundation for AIDS Research (amfAR) in
New York to discuss the conference theme and agenda. Stephen Marks,
Jennifer Leaning, and Sofia Gruskin have agreed to serve on the Advisory
Committee for the conference. In this capacity, they will help to shape
the conference program, which will focus on the relationship between
health, law, and human rights.
Consortium
for Health and Human Rights
The Consortium
continues to meet regularly. In this period, members continued to prepare
for the APHA annual meeting in November. The two-part health and human
rights panel (see above) consisted largely of Consortium members. In
partnership with the Consortium, FXBC continues its work to compile
an updated list of health and human rights courses and syllabi around
the world, for web and possible print publication.
Global
Health Assembly, April 2001
During
this period, planning continued for the global health assembly to be
held April 12–15, 2001, titled “Advancing the Right to Health,” which
FXBC is cosponsoring along with the University of Iowa’s Center for
Human Rights, led by Burns Weston, and a number of other local groups
in the health and medical communities. Stephen Marks has played an instrumental
role in drafting the program and identifying the speakers.
Carnegie
Council on Ethics in International Affairs
As a member
of the Advisory Committee of the Human Rights Initiative of the Carnegie
Council, Stephen Marks is active in integrating health and human rights
concerns into this project. In addition to suggestion authors for an
issue of the initiative’s publication Human Rights Dialogue (see below
under “Dissemination of Information”), he attended a meeting of the
Advisory Committee on October 5–6 in New York City.
At
HSPH and Harvard
Africa
Now!
The Harvard
AIDS Institute, in collaboration with the FXB Center and other partners,
convened a summit on U.S.-based responses to AIDS in Africa, bringing
together approximately 125 political, academic, business, and NGO-based
leaders from Africa and the U.S., including one head of state and several
ministers of health from Africa, on November 12–14. Stephen Marks and
Sofia Gruskin were both on the steering committee for the summit.
The summit
initiated dialogue among international leaders about the role of the
U.S. in addressing AIDS in Africa by comparing existing U.S. efforts
with a survey of African priorities. It also advanced the efforts underway
by the UN and U.S. government agencies to create a coordinated response
to the crisis. The summit adopted a framework document entitled “Principles
of Collaboration when Confronting AIDS in Africa,” complementing the
UN’s International Partnership Against AIDS in Africa.
During the
summit, Stephen Marks also co-chaired a working group meeting on human
rights education, and Sofia Gruskin presented the draft Principles of
Collaboration to the plenary group. They both continue to participate
in the steering committee, which is working on a post-summit campaign
to help address AIDS in Africa and to disseminate the summit’s conclusions.
Weatherhead
Center for International Affairs
During
this period, Jennifer Leaning, Stephen Marks, and Jenna LeMieux met
several times with Professor Herb Kelman, Director of the Program on
International Conflict Analysis and Resolution (PICAR), and Donna Hicks,
Deputy Director of PICAR, to draft a project proposal for the Weatherhead
Initiative. The proposal, titled “Institutionalizing Interactive Problem
Solving for Conflict Resolution: Feasibility Assessment of an International
Facilitating Service,” was submitted as a joint FXB-PICAR project, and
will be entered into the University-wide competition for funding. The
winner will be selected in early 2001.
HSPH
Working Group on Women, Gender and Health
The HSPH Working
Group on Women, Gender and Health (WGH), on which Sofia Gruskin serves,
continues to meet monthly to discuss ways to foster the advancement
of these issues in at the School. In this period, the group sponsored
two seminars at HSPH, one on gender and occupational health, the other
on gender-based violence and human rights. Planning also continued for
a new course, WGH 210d, with a focus on women’s mental health.
Dissemination
of Information
Health
and Human Rights Journal
During
this period, Vol. 5, No. 1 was sent to the printer. The issue covers
topics including women’s mental health and human rights, sex workers
in India, HIV/AIDS and other health issues in South Africa, informed
consent issues in a study involving survivors of Srebrenica, and NGO
efforts to protect and promote the right to health in Latin America.
It is expected to be mailed to subscribers before the end of January.
We have received
many submissions in response to the call for papers for Vol. 5, No.
2, the special issue on children’s health and human rights to appear
in 2001. In this period, initial editorial review and peer review began,
and invitations were sent out to several other possible contributors.
Working
Papers Series
In this
period, the FXB Center relaunched its working papers series with the
following publications:
- Arjun
Sengupta, “The Right to Development as a Human Right”
- Daniel
Tarantola, “Building on the Synergy between Health and Human Rights:
A Global Perspective”
- Allison Smith
Estelle, “International Responses to Drug Abuse among Young People:
Assessing the Integration of Human Rights Obligations” (winner of
the 2000 FXB Essay Award)
- Sofia Gruskin
and Daniel Tarantola, “Health and Human Rights”
Health
and Human Rights in Times of Peace and Times of Conflict
The FXB
Center is preparing to publish the proceedings of this symposium, held
on April 12, 2000, in New York. In this period, editorial and production
work continued. The finished publication is expected to go to press
early in 2001.
Human
Rights Dialogue
The director
of this publication of the Carnegie Council on Ethics in International
Affairs asked Stephen Marks to prepare a special issue on health and
human rights, to appear in the spring of 2001. He met with Dialogue
staff and began work on identifying authors for this publication.
Harvard
Public Health Review
The current
issue of the Harvard Public Health Review, which appeared in December,
contains a number of items on the Center. It features a profile of Stephen
Marks and favorable mentions of Health and Human Rights: A Reader
(ed. J. Mann, S. Gruskin, M. Grodin, and G. Annas) and Humanitarian
Crises: The Medical and Public Health Response (ed. J. Leaning,
S. M. Briggs, and L. C. Chen) in its Bookshelf column.
FXB
Center Seminar Series
In this
period, the 2000–2001 Seminar Series presented two speakers:
Susannah
Sirkin, Deputy Director of Physicians for Human Rights, “Mobilizing
Health Professionals to Promote Human Rights: The Experience of Physicians
for Human Rights” (October 24)
Michael
Grodin, MD, BU School of Public Health, “The Boston Center for Refugee
Health and Human Rights: Caring for Survivors of Torture and Refugee
Trauma” (December 12)
Both
talks were attended by an enthusiastic audience of students, faculty,
and members of the public.
Staff
and Administration
Nancy Briton
In this
period, Nancy Briton joined the FXB Center as a statistician working
with Gilbert Holleufer on his People and War project.
Sarah
Martin
Also in
this period, Sarah Martin joined the FXB Center as a staff assistant.
She will be working with the Program on Humanitarian Crises and Human
Rights to do research and provide administrative support.
Program
Activities
Program
on International Health and Human Rights
Linkages
and Partnerships: HSPH and Harvard
Enhancing
Care Initiative (ECI)
This
project is jointly carried out by the Harvard AIDS Institute, the FXB
Center, other entities within Harvard, and counterpart institutions
in Brazil, Senegal, Thailand, and South Africa. ECI has been developing
a conceptual and practical framework on how to assess, plan for, and
evaluate care for people living with HIV/AIDS, which includes human
rights and gender-sensitive approaches. Sofia Gruskin, one of the four
Harvard investigators, supports management of the Initiative, works
with each of the teams to ensure consistency in research and integration
of human rights within their research agendas. She remains the focal
point for the Brazilian team.
In this period,
a great deal of time was spent on internal management, including staffing
changes, and restructuring of work with the teams. Weekly conference
calls, rotating among the teams, have been instituted, and increased
communication concerning research directions and implementation has
been prioritized. Also in this period, Pikul Nantachaipan of the Thai
team came to spend several months with us in order to deepen her understanding
of human rights and how to apply a human rights framework to the work
of the Thai team. Sofia Gruskin met with her on a regular basis to guide
her studies and approach to the design of the human rights research
tool. Sofia Gruskin will also be traveling to Thailand in January to
facilitate its implementation.
Linkages
and Partnerships: National and International Institutions
UNAIDS
Sofia
Gruskin continues to work extensively on projects with UNAIDS, including
the UNAIDS Human Rights Strategy and discussions and efforts toward
enunciation of the Global AIDS Strategy. UNAIDS cosponsors met in October
to discuss the revised Global AIDS Strategy. The document was completed
after further revisions in November. It was brought to the Programme
Coordinating Board (PCB) at the December meeting in Rio de Janeiro,
where it was approved as the new Global Strategy.
Also in this
period, revisions moved forward for the Reference Handbook on the Convention
on the Rights of the Child and HIV/AIDS. This handbook is intended to
serve as a basic reference source for the Committee on the Rights of
the Child (CRC) in its discussions with States parties on the rights
of the child in the context of HIV/AIDS. It will also contain information
on best practices.
WHO
The program
continues its collaboration with various departments of WHO, including
Reproductive Health, Children’s Health, Women’s Health, and the newly
created Health and Human Rights Unit. Sofia Gruskin is an External Advisor
on Health and Human Rights for the organization, which entails offering
substance and technical assistance when requested. Biweekly phone calls
with the Health and Human Rights Unit have been instituted to ensure
coherence in human rights work throughout the organization.
Work continued
on WHO’s Health and Human Rights Strategy. The program also offered
substantial written technical input into work on mental health and human
rights towards production of the 2001 World Health Report, which will
focus on mental health, and the document being prepared for World TB
Day 2001 (March 24), which will focus on the linkage between human rights
and tuberculosis. Likewise, in preparation for Human Rights Day 2000
(celebrated on December 11 this year), program staff reviewed fact sheets
prepared by various departments within WHO, including Children’s Health,
Mental Health, HIV/AIDS, Women’s Health, Disabilities, Reproductive
Health, and Violence and Injuries Prevention on the work they are doing
in relation to human rights, and suggested changes to ensure the technical
accuracy of the information presented.
In this period,
revisions continued on the Memorandum of Understanding between FXBC
and WHO. The memorandum now encompasses the following current and projected
areas of collaboration:
- Production
of an annotated bibliography on health and human rights, with updates
to be done each year for two years.
- Identification
of health and human rights actors and institutions doing work on a
global level. This information will be stored in an online database.
- Articulation
of WHO’s strategy for the Human Rights Treaty Bodies, which will seek
to bring more consistency to the organization’s approach to working
with the various bodies.
- Joint
production of a paper on poverty, equity, health, and human rights
with noted economist Paula Braveman.
- Health and human
rights training for WHO staff. A new annex to the MOU has been agreed
upon concerning the training of WHO headquarters, regional, and in-country
staff on health and human rights.
- Human rights
guidance for the WHO initiative “Making Pregnancy Safer” (MPS). MPS
in Mozambique is WHO’s project for integrating a human rights approach
into national efforts towards reducing maternal mortality. In this
period, Sofia Gruskin traveled to Mozambique for several days of intensive
work on the initiative with WHO headquarters personnel and local partners.
Specifically, the objectives were to support the creation of an MPS
Mozambique Multi-Sectoral Team to lead the initiative, to agree on
a common plan of action for the integration of MPS into the national
strategic safe motherhood plan, and to meet with donors and other
interested parties working on the area of maternal and neonatal mortality.
In preparation for the trip, Adriane Martin Hilber, WHO HQ technical
officer on MPS-Mozambique, traveled to Boston and worked with Mindy
Roseman and Sofia Gruskin for three days, developing materials on
maternal and neonatal mortality and human rights.
Operationalizing
Cairo and Beijing: A Training Initiative in Gender and Reproductive
Health
This leadership
training initiative, conducted in partnership with the World Health
Organization and the Women’s Health Project, University of the Witwatersrand,
South Africa, created a pilot course that has run four times in South
Africa, as well as in China, Australia, Argentina, and Kenya, in preparation
for production of a global curriculum in 2001.
The final
version of the written curriculum, titled “Gender and Rights: Transforming
Health Systems,” which was field-tested in South Africa on August 28–September
15 with uninitiated trainers using the curriculum to teach the course,
was revised in this period. Sofia Gruskin spent time in this period
participating in an extensive review of each of the modules to ensure
consistency in relation to the inclusion of human rights and a logical
coherence more generally.
UNIFEM
Sofia
Gruskin has been invited, along with Geeta Gupta of ICRW and Stephen
Lewis, formerly of UNICEF, to serve in a formal advisory capacity for
UNIFEM’s newly created HIV/AIDS program. Several meetings were held
in this period in order to help shape and move this program forward.
Centers
for Disease Control
Sofia
Gruskin continues to serve as a technical advisor to the three CDC-funded
projects taking place within the U.S. on structural interventions to
reduce HIV incidence.
Linkages
and Partnerships: NGOs
Amnesty
International
The
FXB Center continues to engage in a number of activities with Amnesty
International, both nationally and internationally. Sofia Gruskin remains
a member of the AIUSA Mandate Committee and now has responsibility for
helping to coordinate the AIUSA section’s approach to economic, social,
and cultural rights. In this capacity, she participated in a number
of meetings and conference calls and in the preparation of the section
response in relation to changes in the mandate.
International
Federation of Red Cross and Red Crescent Societies
In this
period, discussions began with Federation Headquarters concerning a
joint training on AIDS and human rights, to be held in conjunction with
the Fifth International Conference on Home and Community Care for Persons
Living with HIV/AIDS (Chiang Mai, Thailand, December 2001).
Publications
The
Lancet
In this
period, Sofia Gruskin’s piece with Bebe Loff, “Getting Serious about
the Right to Health,” concerning the recent adoption by the UN Committee
on Economic, Social and Cultural Rights of General Comment 14 on the
Right to Health, was published in The Lancet (Vol. 356, No. 9239, 21
October 2000).
Program
on Humanitarian Crises and Human Rights
Linkages
and Partnerships: HSPH and Harvard
Program
on Humanitarian Policy and Conflict Research
Jennifer
Leaning chairs the Advisory Committee for this program, based at the
Harvard School of Public Health, which was launched this fall. Following
an Advisory Committee meeting on December 5, a reception hosted by Claude
Bruderlein, the Swiss Representative to the UN, marked the formal opening
of the program.
Field
Mission to Kosovo
In October–November,
Jennifer Leaning traveled to Kosovo with the International Health Systems
Group (IHSG) at HSPH and Physicians for Human Rights on a field mission
to assess the potential for professional capacity and institution building
with physicians and other health care workers. A return mission is planned
for April with the IHSG team.
Expert
Assessment Team on Sanctions
Jennifer Leaning
has been working to develop an expert assessment team to evaluate the
humanitarian impact of sanctions. The core team continues to meet, and
a report on feasibility for UNICEF is in preparation.
Linkages
and Partnerships: National and International Institutions
International
Committee of the Red Cross
On December
6–7, Jennifer Leaning and Gilbert Holleufer hosted several members of
the ICRC. The visit included an expert consultation on human security,
with participants drawn from HSPH and other schools at Harvard.
Partition
of India Project
Jennifer
Leaning is conducting a study on the feasibility of undertaking a large
project on the effects of the partition of India. Initial findings from
the field are promising, and a review seminar is planned for the spring.
The project would be done in collaboration with the MIT-Mellon Inter-University
Program on Non-Governmental Organizations and Forced Migration.
Linkages
and Partnerships: NGOs
Médecins
sans Frontières
In this
period, Jennifer Leaning continued work on revising a proposal on collaboration
between MSF and FXBC.
Mellon
Foundation
In this period,
Jennifer Leaning received a grant from the Mellon Foundation for the
development of a curriculum at HSPH on humanitarian crises, beginning
with the MPH program and then expanding to the two-year programs. The
grant will fund a part-time assistant and will contribute to the salary
of a senior faculty member to be hired jointly by HSPH and Tufts University.
Advisory
Group on Research Priorities in Emergencies
Jennifer
Leaning continues to participate in the ethics subgroup of this advisory
group, which has been discussing informed consent issues.
Publications
USAID
In this
period, Jennifer Leaning completed a working paper for USAID on human
security and submitted it to the Crisis and Transition Unit of USAID’s
African Bureau. A working paper for the Harvard Center on Population
and Development Studies is in preparation. A proposal for Year Two work
(case studies) has been submitted to USAID/CERTI.
Physicians
for Human Rights
Jennifer
Leaning has contributed to a report by Physicians for Human Rights on
medical human rights violations in Kosovo, due out early in 2001.
Program
on Human Rights in Human Development
In
this period, Visiting Fellow Arjun Sengupta spent two weeks at the FXB
Center, working on his third report on the right to development, and
meeting extensively with Stephen Marks regarding the Right to Development
Project.
The Project
began to take shape during this period, as the International Advisory
Committee held its first meeting at the FXB Center on December 12. Advisory
Committee members in attendance were Clarence Dias (International Center
for Law and Development), Asbjorn Eide (Norwegian Institute for Human
Rights), Michael Reich (Chair, Population and International Health Dept.,
HSPH), and Allan Hill (HSPH). In attendance via phone from Geneva were
Stephanie Grant (Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights) and
Thord Palmlund (UNDP, NYC).
The goal of
the project is to establish 6 small-scale projects applying a human
rights–based approach to development. The December 12 meeting reviewed
the background and function of the Advisory Committee, the general expectations
of the project, staffing needs of the project and advice from members
regarding recruitment, the framework for research and workshops, and
the organization of country projects.
As part of
his exploration of suitable partners in developing countries to participate
in this project, Stephen Marks went to Mali on November 19–23. He attended
the inauguration of the African Learning Institution for Human Rights
Education (ALIHRE) and People’s Decade for Human Rights Education in
Mali (PDHRE-Mali) in Bamako; he also taught the training of trainees
organized by PDHRE-Mali in Silengué, Mali.
Linkages
and Partnerships: National and International Institutions
United
Nations Development Programme
During
this period, discussions continued regarding cooperation with the HURIST
program of UNDP. The project proposes to establish small-scale projects
applying a human rights–based approach to development in Cambodia and
Ghana, as the first of several country-specific projects on sustainable
human development.
In addition,
Stephen Marks traveled to Rio de Janeiro to participate in the UNDP-sponsored
Second Global Forum on Human Development, held on October 9–10. He chaired
a panel on October 9 titled “Legitimizing Human Rights within Development,”
at which he also gave a talk titled “The Human Rights Framework: Its
Relevance for Development.”
Publications
Princeton
Project on Universal Jurisdiction
During
this period, Stephen Marks completed his paper for the Princeton Project
on Universal Jurisdiction, titled “The Hissène Habré Case: The Law and
Politics of Universal Jurisdiction.” The paper focuses on efforts to
hold Habré accountable for the torture and arbitrary killing of approximately
40,000 people during his mandate as president of Chad. The paper will
be published by Princeton University Press as part of an anthology put
together by the project. On November 3, he participated in a conference
on universal jurisdiction held in Boston at the New England School of
Law. On November 9–11, he presented the paper at the first of two meetings
organized by the Princeton Project, attended by approximately two dozen
scholars. The second meeting, to include a gathering of international
jurists, will be held in January 2001. The purpose of the project is
to examine the principled terms under which universal jurisdiction should
be accepted by the international community.