image image Harvard Public Health NOW
image

Search Archives
image
December 12, 2003
APHA Meeting: 21st Century Challenges and Opportunities in Public Health

image
Harvey Fineberg
For all intents and purposes, the United States does not have a health care "system," according to Robert Graham, acting deputy director, Agency for Healthcare Research Quality (AHRQ) and former director of the Health Resources and Services Administration. Instead, he said, the U.S. has developed "choices" for health care that lead to inconsistent coverage and experiences. Graham spoke at the "President’s Session: Challenges and Opportunities Confronting the Public Health System in the 21st Century" at APHA on November 17.

Because people differ in gender, insurance status, geographical locations and other factors, it is not surprising that treatments vary, he said. The objective of a health care system should be to make outcomes less inequitable, not identical, he said.

AHRQ has been federally mandated to produce a series of annual reports on the variables that underpin health care in the U.S. The first report is expected to be released by the end of the year, he said. So far, data indicate that when quality of patient care increases, disparities narrow, he said.

In addition to addressing health disparities, public health faces other challenges, said Harvey Fineberg, president of the Institute of Medicine and former HSPH dean. Despite the enormous number of preventable deaths in the country each year, only five percent of the nation’s health care dollar is spent on population health and prevention; 95 percent is spent on personal health and treatment.

Why is prevention so hard to sell, he asked? When successful, prevention is invisible. No one counts the number of children who lived longer because they received a vaccine against pertussis. Prevention lacks the "drama of saving" that accompanies curative medicine, Fineberg noted. Organ transplantations, for example, still grab headlines.

Sheer numbers of people in need can be overwhelming to think about. Americans will rivet their attention on a single child stuck in a well but have a hard time thinking about millions of children trapped in poverty, he noted.

There are financial challenges as well. The return on investing in prevention can be a long time coming, Fineberg said, and those who benefit are not always the investors. Besides that, a double standard exists between preventive medicine and treatment. Prevention is expected to return a net savings for every $1 spent, whereas the same is not asked of treatment, he said.

In the future, Fineberg said that he would like to see a more universally accessible and person-centered, not provider-centered, public health system. The system should be evidence-based, integrated and quality-driven, he said, with a greater population and ecological perspective.

The IOM frequently publishes reports on aspects of public health and other health care issues. The reports can be accessed at http://www.iom.edu/.


Harvard Public Health NOW is published biweekly by the
Office of Communications
Harvard School of Public Health
665 Huntington Ave., SPH 1-1312
Boston, Massachusetts 02115
617-432-6052
Editor and Layout: Christina Roache
Contributing Writer: Paula Hartman Cohen
Calendar Editor: Melitta King
Photos Credits: Dave Bush; Suzanne Camarata; CDC; Richard Chase; HCRA; HSPH Center for Health Communication; Lagniappe Studio Inc., courtesy APHA; Graham Ramsay; Christina Roache


Archived Issues || HSPH Home

Copyright, 2009,  President and Fellows of Harvard College

Around the School Exams and Defenses John Kerry's Health Care Policy Advisor Suggests HSPH Students Get Involved in Politics Calendar Harvard Center Names New Director and Executive Director Archived Issues Office of Communications Murray Returns to HSPH and will Lead University Global Health Effort APHA Meeting: HSPH Alumni from across Country Gather at Special Reception APHA Meeting: New CDC Analysis System Gives Local Health Trend Data APHA Meeting: Massachusetts Slips Two Spots in National Health Survey APHA Meeting: Raucous Opening Session APHA Meeting Draws More than 13,500 Public Health Professionals Richmond Wins Heinz Award Demographer Lee Suggests Explanation for Why Humans Live Well Past Reproductive Years January 2004 Marks Third Annual National Mentoring Month Flu Season Under Way, Free Vaccines Still Available at UHS for Harvard Community