image image Harvard Public Health NOW
image

Search Archives
image
December 12, 2003
APHA Meeting: Raucous Opening Session

image
Zackie Achmat
"The greatest threat to public health worldwide today is George Bush," asserted South African AIDS activist Zackie Achmat at the Opening General Session of the APHA on November 16. His statement was met by deafening cheers from the approximately 6,000 audience members. They later applauded other speakers’ comments castigating a Medicare prescription drug bill proposal backed by the Bush administration and the lack of universal health care in the country.

Achmat disclosed his HIV-positive status in 1998 and founded the Treatment Action Campaign. He has since fought to bring affordable AIDS drugs to South Africa, refusing to take the medications himself until they were more widely available to his compatriots. The South African government recently announced plans for a national AIDS drugs program.

His statement about Bush was not designed to bring the rapturous applause it received, he said. Instead, Bush’s policies leave him with an "enormous pain in my heart," he said.

In January, Bush announced a program that would provide $15 billion over five years to fight global AIDS. No money had yet been appropriated at the time of the APHA meeting, asserted Achmat, and he charged that the announcement was an attempt to buy the silence of poor countries at a time when the looming war in Iraq was receiving heavy international criticism.

"All of you here know that just like the weapons of mass destruction in Iraq, that $15 billion is a lie," he said,

Bush had originally endorsed an outlay of $3 billion in the first year of the program but later reduced the number to $2 billion. The day after Achmat’s speech, Congressional lawmakers announced a tentative foreign aid bill that, if approved, would provide $2.4 billion for the program in the first year. The bill requires final votes in the House and Senate.

Achmat said that the Bush administration’s support for the "ABC" (Abstinence, Be faithful, or use Condoms if A and B are not practiced) model of AIDS prevention is too simplistic.

"To say to people ‘Be faithful’–without saying that you also have a right and a duty to use a condom–kills them," he said.

Achmat applauded the use of international pressure to bring down the costs of AIDS drugs in South Africa, which were as high as $650 per month when he started Treatment Action Campaign. Now they cost about $18 per month in the public health care sector, he said–a deal that President Bill Clinton helped broker between drug companies and the South African government, Achmat said.

"Let not money be appropriated for war but for peace and for public health," he said.

The Opening General Session took place a little more than a week before Congress approved a Medicare bill that provides coverage for some prescription drugs but also gives private insurance companies a larger role in the federal entitlement program.

image
Barbara Lee
U.S. Representative Barbara Lee spoke out against the bill in her speech at the Opening Session, charging that the bill practically privatizes the program.

Lee said, "Instead of creating universal health care, we will be going in precisely the wrong direction: toward rising Medicare costs for seniors, forced entry into HMOs and an enormous gap in prescription drug coverage that will leave millions of seniors still scrambling to pay for medication."

Health care should be a basic human right, not an industry, she asserted.

The APHA issued a statement describing its opposition to the bill on November 18, one week prior to its Congressional approval.

image
Georges Benjamin
"The bill lacks an adequate prescription drug benefit for millions of seniors who urgently need and deserve a comprehensive and affordable prescription drug benefit provided through the traditional Medicare program," said Georges Benjamin, executive director of the association, in a press release. "Moreover, the plan fundamentally weakens the Medicare program itself. We firmly believe that seniors should not be asked to accept an inadequate prescription drug benefit. Congress should spend the time to get the job done right."

The statement criticized the failure of the bill to ensure guaranteed access to a prescription drug benefit for seniors who already have some pharmaceutical coverage; large gaps in coverage; and the prospect that some seniors may need to choose less expensive private-sector managed care plans in the wake of expected rising Medicare premiums.

The full APHA statement is available at http://www.apha.org/news/press/2003/medicarebill.htm.

Lee also described her reintroduction of a bill that would establish universal health care in the U.S., similar to the National Health System in Britain. H.R. 3080, the United States Universal Health Service Act, would create an entitlement to free health care and supplemental services, with an emphasis on prevention and wellness strategies.

"It is a national embarrassment that the United States is the only industrialized country in the world without health insurance for all," she said.

Lee received one of three APHA Distinguished Public Health Legislator of the Year Awards. Also honored were U.S. House Minority Leader Nancy Pelosi, whose aide accepted the award on her behalf, and Maine Gov. John Elias Baldacci, who also was not in attendance but provided a videotaped acceptance speech.

image
Jay Glasser
Like Lee, Jay Glasser, president of APHA, spoke about the lack of universal health care in the U.S., stressing that public health is part and parcel of the national health care system. Using an analogy to the massive power outage that affected millions of Americans last summer, Glasser noted that between 43 and 60 million Americans lack health insurance in any given year–in response, "we need to power up the public health grid."

More than 70 million people go without health insurance for a significant part of two years, he continued. "Imagine speaking to an audience of 70+ million people, saying ‘You do not count in our great nation’," said Glasser.

Poor children are twice as likely to lack health insurance as better-off children, he noted, and the discrepancies do not end there. Health status differs dramatically among groups of Americans.

"APHA’s long-term commitment to eliminating racial and ethnic disparities is something we must renew every day and every year," he said.


Harvard Public Health NOW is published biweekly by the
Office of Communications
Harvard School of Public Health
665 Huntington Ave., SPH 1-1312
Boston, Massachusetts 02115
617-432-6052
Editor and Layout: Christina Roache
Contributing Writer: Paula Hartman Cohen
Calendar Editor: Melitta King
Photos Credits: Dave Bush; Suzanne Camarata; CDC; Richard Chase; HCRA; HSPH Center for Health Communication; Lagniappe Studio Inc., courtesy APHA; Graham Ramsay; Christina Roache


Archived Issues || HSPH Home

Copyright, 2009,  President and Fellows of Harvard College

Around the School Exams and Defenses John Kerry's Health Care Policy Advisor Suggests HSPH Students Get Involved in Politics Calendar Harvard Center Names New Director and Executive Director Archived Issues Office of Communications Murray Returns to HSPH and will Lead University Global Health Effort APHA Meeting: HSPH Alumni from across Country Gather at Special Reception APHA Meeting: 21st Century Challenges and Opportunities in Public Health APHA Meeting: New CDC Analysis System Gives Local Health Trend Data APHA Meeting: Massachusetts Slips Two Spots in National Health Survey APHA Meeting Draws More than 13,500 Public Health Professionals Richmond Wins Heinz Award Demographer Lee Suggests Explanation for Why Humans Live Well Past Reproductive Years January 2004 Marks Third Annual National Mentoring Month Flu Season Under Way, Free Vaccines Still Available at UHS for Harvard Community